Amazon Restocking Fee Disputes: Templates and Evidence Checklist for Sellers

Every dollar lost to an Amazon restocking fee is a dollar off your margin, but most sellers never fight back.

Unchallenged fees accumulate across hundreds of orders, quietly eroding profitability. Multiply that across a typical month of returns, and you are looking at thousands left on the table each year.

This guide breaks down exactly how to dispute restocking fees, what evidence Amazon accepts, and how to make the process nearly automatic. You will learn which disputes are winnable, how to organize your evidence, and when to escalate.

Let us turn disputes from a headache into a profit protection strategy.

How restocking fee disputes impact your margins

Every unchallenged restocking fee cuts directly into your bottom line.

Consider this scenario: A seller processing 500 orders monthly with a 3% return rate faces roughly 15 returned items. If just half incur a 20% restocking fee on $50 items, that equals $75 per month. Over a year, that is $900 in potential losses, before accounting for higher-value items or increased order volume.

Here is how unchallenged fees compound based on typical return volumes:

Table 1: Amazon restocking fees and their impact

Automated fee tracking surfaces discrepancies before they become costly surprises.

To protect your margins, you first need to know when a restocking fee is actually eligible for dispute.

Suggested read: From Amazon to Webgility: Tales from an Ecommerce Pro

The 5 most common restocking fee dispute triggers

Most successful disputes fall into five clear categories.

Knowing these triggers helps you focus your effort where you are most likely to win. Choose your battles based on these proven scenarios.

1. Buyer returns item in original condition

Amazon's policy states that fees cannot be charged when buyers return items unopened and on time. Yet this happens frequently due to system errors.

Example: A buyer purchases a $40 desk lamp and returns it unopened within 30 days. You receive it undamaged in original packaging, but Amazon charges a $5 fee anyway. This is fully eligible for dispute.

2. Restocking fee exceeds policy limits

Amazon permits specific maximum fees by category

1. Electronics: Up to 20%
2. Luxury goods: Up to 50%
3. Books: No fees permitted
4. Media (unopened): No fees permitted

Example: A 30% fee is charged on a $200 laptop when policy caps electronics at 20%. The $20 overage is eligible for dispute.

3. Return reason is seller fault, but evidence shows otherwise

Fees are strictly prohibited when returns stem from seller error, such as defective products, damaged shipments, or wrong items sent. However, if your evidence shows the item was shipped correctly and in new condition, you can challenge the fee.

Example: A buyer claims an item is defective, but your photos and records show it was shipped new and undamaged.

Suggested read: How to Manage Amazon Inventory for Better Profits

4. System errors in fee calculation

Amazon's system occasionally misapplies fees through inventory sync issues, refund processing errors, or incorrect category assignment.

Example: A book is charged an electronics restocking fee due to an ASIN mapping error.

5. Policy misinterpretation by Amazon or the buyer

Sometimes fees target returns that fall outside policy scope, such as unopened media, Prime member returns, or items within extended holiday windows.

Example: A Prime member returns an item within the allowed window, but a restocking fee is still charged.

Not every fee is worth disputing; focus on those with clear policy violations or significant dollar amounts. Centralized transaction records make it easier to identify these triggers at scale.

Once you spot a fee that is eligible for dispute, the next step is gathering the right evidence.

Suggested read: Boost Your Amazon Profits With Cost Tracking

What evidence Amazon accepts and how to gather it efficiently

Amazon requires specific, well-documented proof to overturn a restocking fee.

Well-organized, policy-aligned evidence is the difference between a denied and an approved dispute. Incomplete documentation or vague claims are rejected immediately.

Evidence types Amazon accepts:

• Order and return details from Seller Central
• Refund transaction records with fee breakdowns
• Buyer-seller communication logs
• Item condition photos (unopened, damaged, etc.)
• Settlement reports showing fee charges

Supporting evidence:

• Amazon policy screenshots with relevant sections highlighted
• Tracking information proving return timing
• Serial numbers or ASINs for verification
• Comparative pricing data for fee calculations

Suggested read: How to Increase Sales on Amazon

Step-by-step evidence gathering checklist:

1. Download order and return details from Seller Central

Go to Orders > Manage Returns. Export the return reason, dates, and fee amounts. Screenshot the full return request.

2. Retrieve refund and fee transaction records

Export settlement reports for the relevant period. Cross-reference the order ID to confirm the fee amount and date.

3. Gather communication logs

Download all buyer-seller messages from Your Account > Messages from Customers. Export the entire thread with timestamps.

4. Document item condition

Photograph the item upon return, noting the date, order ID, and condition. If you have not received the return, note this in your claim.

Centralize your documentation to save hours on every dispute. Webgility automatically syncs and stores order, refund, and fee records so you are always audit-ready.

With your evidence in hand, here is how to present your case for maximum impact.

Suggested read: The Complete Guide to Ecommerce Accounting

Templates for successful Amazon restocking fee disputes

A clear, professional template saves time and avoids costly miscommunication.

Dispute email/message template

Subject: Restocking Fee Dispute – Order #[Order Number]

Hello Amazon Seller Support,

I am disputing the restocking fee charged on Order #[Order Number] for [Product Name/ASIN]. The item was returned in [describe condition: unopened/original packaging/within return window], which, per Amazon’s policy, does not qualify for a restocking fee.

• Order ID: [Order Number]
• Return date: [Date]
• Fee charged: $[Amount]
• Evidence summary: [Brief description of attached evidence, such as photos, communication, settlement report]
• Policy citation: [Link or quote from Amazon’s restocking fee policy]

Please review the attached documentation and refund the restocking fee.

Thank you,

[Your Name/Store Name]

You can also use this internal tracker worksheet template:

Why this works: Referencing Amazon’s policy shows you know the rules. Summarizing evidence up front makes it easy for support to review your case. Tracking disputes ensures nothing falls through.

Pre-fill these templates with data from your accounting automation platform for even faster submission.

Even with the right templates, sellers often make avoidable mistakes. Here is how to sidestep them.

Suggested read: Amazon Seller Accounting Software Guide

Mistakes to avoid and best practices for Amazon restocking fee disputes

Most failed disputes come down to three preventable mistakes.

Top mistakes include:

Missing documentation

Risk: Claims are denied for lack of proof

How to avoid: Gather and organize all evidence before submitting

Unclear or emotional language

Risk: Support teams may misunderstand your claim

How to avoid: Use clear, factual statements and reference policy directly

Late submission

Risk: Claims filed after Amazon’s 60-day window are automatically rejected

How to avoid: Track deadlines and submit disputes promptly

Best practices to try:

• Respond to returns and disputes within 24-48 hours
• Reference Amazon’s policy directly in every claim
• Keep all evidence organized and accessible in one location
• Track each dispute’s status and outcome to spot patterns

When NOT to dispute:

• Fees clearly allowed by policy
• Low-value disputes that cost more in time than recovery

Automated reminders and centralized records help you avoid missed deadlines and lost evidence.

Streamlining all of this is easier with the right tools. Here is how accounting automation can help.

Suggested read: Large Amazon Seller’s Guide to Expanding Product Lines

How Webgility helps: Building a bulletproof dispute record

Webgility automates the evidence-gathering and reconciliation that make disputes easier to win.

Key features:

Automated fee and refund tracking for Amazon

Webgility captures every Amazon fee at the transaction level, including referral fees, FBA costs, storage charges, and refund adjustments.

This means when Amazon processes a refund or chargeback, the platform logs it immediately and maps it to the original order. You can pull a complete fee history for any transaction in seconds.

Suggested read: How to Automate Ecommerce Bookkeeping

Centralized dashboard for all order and fee records

Every order from Amazon, Shopify, Walmart, and other channels flows into a single dashboard with complete transaction details. 

You see order dates, fulfillment status, payment confirmations, and fee breakdowns in one place. When a dispute arises, you access all supporting documentation without hunting through multiple platforms.

Audit trails for every transaction

Webgility maintains a permanent record of every sync, post, and adjustment with timestamps and system logs.

If Amazon claims a refund was processed incorrectly or a fee was never charged, you have timestamped proof of what actually happened.

When you can prove your case with clean, timestamped records, you win more disputes and recover revenue that would otherwise disappear. Strong documentation also helps you identify patterns in chargebacks or refund abuse, allowing you to tighten policies and increase Amazon sales by reducing avoidable losses.

Book a demo with Webgility today.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

When can I dispute an Amazon restocking fee?

You can dispute a fee if it violates Amazon’s policy, such as being charged for unopened returns, exceeding category limits, or due to system errors. Always review the latest policy before submitting a claim.

How long does it take for Amazon to review a restocking fee dispute?

Most disputes are resolved within a couple of weeks, but timelines can vary depending on the complexity and completeness of your documentation.

What documentation should I include in my dispute?

Include order details, refund records, communication logs, and photos of the item’s condition. Referencing Amazon’s policy directly in your claim strengthens your case.

Is there a time limit for submitting a restocking fee dispute?

Amazon typically requires disputes to be submitted within a specific window after the refund date, so act quickly and check the current policy.